HomeFinance And LawMulti-sportsGlobal

Risk considerations for sport’s return from lockdown

FC Internazionale face Juventus during Serie A match behind closed doors in Turin, Italy (Photo by Claudio Villa - Inter/Inter via Getty Images)

As the sports industry prepares to resume behind closed doors amid the Coronavirus lockdown, David Griffiths, a senior member of the sports and entertainment team at Miller Insurance, considers the event management and risk assessment considerations that event organisers need to factor into their planning.

With reports suggesting that global revenues for 2020 will be halved and that some clubs and events may not be financially robust enough to survive a continuing revenue hiatus, there is an understandable desire to get sport up and running as soon as possible.

David Griffiths, senior member of the sports and entertainment team at Miller Insurance

But the impetus behind discussions to re-start sport is not driven solely by commercial considerations. Lockdown has emphasised the importance of sport in national life and its return will deliver a much-needed morale-boost to millions.

Consequently we are witnessing an active and public dialogue as the world’s biggest football leagues – Spain’s La Liga, the English Premier League and Italy’s Serie A – look to conclude the 2019-20 season while Formula 1 also has advanced plans to race again by creating a ‘biosphere’ Covid-19 free zone around its events.

Elsewhere, Korea’s professional football and baseball leagues are already back, with a reported 3.4m Twitter views of the K-League restart and a further 234k views on YouTube.

The German Bundesliga is already under way, while tentative steps have been taken to re-start tennis with a minor pro event in Germany. In the United States, Rory McIlroy is among the stars to play in a charity golf tournament while Professional Bull Riding – an increasingly attractive TV property – has also held its first event since the introduction of lockdown.

But as different sports prepare to resume, they are all aware that they won’t be returning to business as usual. They face a changed world in which fans – not just a major source of revenue but the living backdrop and soundtrack to sport – are absent. For the foreseeable future, any sport which can take place is highly likely to do so behind closed doors, with an increased reliance on broadcasters to reach fans that are unable to attend in person.

This is uncharted territory with many key factors out of the control of event organisers and clubs. As a result, they face a raft of fresh challenges and new considerations. For events to take place under the new norm, where government advice has to be followed at all times, requires a thorough review and revision of established processes and procedures – in effect a new Playbook.

Thorough risk assessment and the development of operational and financial strategies to mitigate that risk is central to the planning of any event or the running of any organisation. And while it might be tempting to imagine that events played in empty stadiums would present fewer risks because they have fewer moving parts (no catering, hospitality or retail, for example) and the absence of a crowd reduces the potential for incidents and accidents in certain areas, the reality is very different.

New and different risk

In fact, events staged behind closed doors at a time of tremendous fear over personal and public health give rise to a new portfolio of potential risk which must be factored into event planning and wider commercial considerations.

Among the key areas of risk is the supply chain on which every event relies. Under normal circumstances the chain is long, varied and complex, covering everything from catering and hospitality through to security, publishing services (programmes) retail, first aid and medical, the list goes on.

While the absence of spectators means that there are fewer components to the chain – there will be no hospitality for example – the reality is that key elements, like security and medical, become more important than ever.

The behind-closed-doors Bundesliga fixture between Werder Bremen and Bayer Leverkusen (Photo by Lars Reinefeld – Pool/Getty Images)

The pandemic has hit businesses hard and all partners are likely have suffered. Event organisers and managers need to be confident that partner organisations remain able to deliver and adapt their services. The reality is that while some may be in reasonable financial shape, they may have furloughed staff and be unable to mobilise a skilled team in time.

It’s also essential to be confident that partners are reviewing and revising their own procedures to meet new requirements. That includes staff training and their own supply and procurement conditions, a lot of which is delivered in different, often virtual, working conditions. The duty of care of organisers will mean giving themselves more extensive reassurance that the safety protocols are being followed through the supply chain.

Health and safety

Event organisers have a responsibility for everybody operating on site. These range from ground staff who have to ensure the sporting surface and other facilities are ready for the restart, to the cleaners responsible for the changing rooms and areas before and after events. Then there are non-employed or contracted service providers which include broadcasters and media as well as, possibly, volunteer service providers such as the St John’s Ambulance.

Naturally, health and safety risks are different to those faced under normal circumstances and many new considerations arise because of the virus and demand a root and branch review of procedures to ensure they remain effective under the new conditions.

Perhaps the most obvious is testing for Covid-19 itself. Without a test clearance nobody will likely be able to operate within the cordon sanitaire around the event. All event day staff, whether employed directly or outsourced will likely have to be tested and cleared. That increases the risk of suppliers not being able to meet their obligations.

Organisers will also have to be confident in the levels of training that all event day staff have received, and in their ability to operate safely and effectively under changed circumstances.

Secure venues

With the possibility of returning sports events taking place at third party venues, another series of potential risks arises. Liaison and collaboration with the venue owners is essential to ensure that their management teams are able to contribute to delivering an event successfully and safely. It is vital to be clear on boundaries of responsibility and liability with other parties involved in staging the event.

Make no mistake, the sports economy is suffering badly and a return to action is vital for businesses and for millions of fans.

Reviewing and revising event management and risk assessment processes has an important role to play in aiding that recovery. Demonstrating that processes are fit for purpose under the new normal and achieving a new level of information sharing and communication among stakeholders will give comfort to insurers and help ensure that events can take place to meet the expectations of broadcasters, sponsors and a sports-hungry public.

The world has changed, nothing can be taken for granted and every aspect of event organisation, processes and procedures must be analysed, and the risks assessed through the prism of the new realities we face. That said, there is a willingness from all those involved in any aspect of sport to facilitate a return to action. With a diligent approach keeping a close eye on Government guidance, there is every prospect of a successful return over the coming weeks and months.

Most recent

SportBusiness examines the pros and cons of some of the equipment available to reassure fans and reduce the risk of contagion when they are allowed back into sport stadiums.

Mixed-gender professional tennis league will hold its entire season at The Greenbrier in West Virginia this summer, becoming one of the first sports events in US to be held in front of limited spectators. Bob Williams reports.

There have been positive tests, protocol breaches and postponements, but nothing has been able to derail the project.

Ricardo Fort, who as Coca-Cola vice-president of global sports partnerships oversees one of the largest sports sponsorship portfolios in the entire world, discusses the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and the prospects of recovery.